Referrals to the Appeal Court by the Secretary of State

1928 to 1999

 

Name of appellant

Referral date

Outcome

1.  Oscar Slater
1928
Conviction quashed
2.  Robert Gallacher
1951
Appeal dismissed
3.  James Higgins
1956
Appeal dismissed
4.  McCran
1961
Appeal dismissed
5.  Douglas Barr 
1979
Conviction quashed
6.  John Preece 
1981
Conviction quashed
7.  Alan Pocock
1986
Conviction quashed
8.  Ernest Barrie
1988
Conviction quashed
9.  Graham Marland
1989
Conviction quashed
10. William Kilpatrick     }
1991}
Appeals dismissed}
11. Christopher McEwen}
1991}
Appeals dismissed}
12. Stewart Dickson
1992
Murder conviction amended to culpable homicide
13. George Beattie
1993 
Appeal dismissed
14. Francis Dougan
1993
Appeal dismissed
15. Thomas Campbell} 
1996}
Appeal dismissed}
16. Joseph Steele      }
1996}
Appeal dismissed}
17. Alexander Hall
1997
Conviction quashed
18. Ronald Stobo
1997
Conviction quashed
19. John McLay(McKay)
1997
Appeal still to be heard 
(as at 3 February 1999)
 

Go back to Chapter 16: Miscarriages of Justice in Scotland


With thanks to: Fred Thorne (Scottish Office) and Barbara Goodison (Leeds University)
jinerr-2\www\scotlist
© Clive Walker, 1999